MetaScan 3: Emerging Technologies
Emerging technologies are laying the groundwork for decades to come, with major impacts anticipated in every aspect of our lives. Canadians will have to work together to ensure that the right policies and institutions are in place to allow for a prosperous and resilient future. Policy Horizons Canada’s latest foresight study examines how digital, bio, nano and neuroscience technologies will shape the Canadian economy and society over the next 10 to 15 years.
This 2013 foresight study on emerging technologies is a collaborative effort that builds upon the 2012 report: MetaScan 2: Building Resilience in the Transition to a Digital Economy and a Networked Society. More than 90 experts from government, the private sector, civil society and academia were interviewed over the course of this study. We greatly appreciate their expertise and insights in the areas of biotechnology, nanotechnology and neuroscience. The full interviewee list can be found in the Consultations and Interviews section. Special thanks go to Jack Smith and to Karl Schroeder.
Horizons works as a matrix organization. Many people played leadership roles in the research and development of content for this report. The MetaScan 3 team was led by Peter Padbury and Steffen Christensen and included Greg Wilburn, Jean Kunz and Duncan Cass-Beggs. The Horizons staff members who led or participated in numerous interviews, workshops and sub-projects that shaped this study, included: Katherine Antal, Imran Arshad, Teresa Bellefontaine, Martin Berry, Stefanie Bowles, David Cavett-Goodwin, Colin Dobson, Alain Denhez, Pierre-Olivier DesMarchais, Nicola Gaye, Roxanne Hamel, Blaise Hébert, Eliza Lavoie, Andrew MacDonald, Marissa Martin, Peter Reinecke, Julie Saumure, Cara Vanayan, Jean-Philippe Veilleux and Nancy White. As well, Horizons' corporate staff – Wanda Baburek, Marie de Beaumont, Louis-Philippe Gascon, Kelly Ann Lambe and Claudia Meneses – helped in other ways. Special thanks to our Directors General Paul De Civita and Judy Watling for strategic oversight, Naomi Kühn for graphic design, layout and illustration, and to Martin Berry for the supplementary 3D illustrations.
Broadly speaking, there are two types of technological innovation: incremental and disruptive. Incremental changes lead to refinements in processes and products. Disruptive technologies produce radical or abrupt changes that challenge and transform larger social, economic, environmental and/or governance systems. This foresight study examines how four emerging technologies (digital technologies, biotechnologies, nanotechnologies and neuroscience technologies) could drive disruptive social and economic change over the next 10 to 15 years.
These technologies will impact almost every sector of the economy. One of the most disruptive features of several of the technologies is they increase productivity with fewer workers. Artificial intelligence (like Apple's Siri) combined with data analytics could dramatically change the service sector with fewer workers. In a growing number of sectors, 3D printing could change the economics and location of manufacturing. Synthetic biology could change the economics and flow of raw materials in agriculture, forestry, energy and mining. Governments, business and society will have to work together to ensure there are innovative policies and institutions in place to ride the next wave of technological change. The next 10 to 15 years will be an era of transition. Almost every major piece of infrastructure will likely be under pressure to keep up in areas like skills development, health care, transportation and security. Ignoring or underestimating the rate of change could very well undermine our competitiveness, preparedness and resilience.
This study is based on wide research and interviews with more than 90 experts. The technologies in this study are at different stages of maturity and are moving at different speeds. All are expected to have disruptive impacts within 15 years and some much sooner. Some technologies may be rejected by Canada as too risky, but perhaps welcomed by others. The four technologies are laying the foundation for the global economy for the next 50 years. A lead time of 10 to 15 years is needed to take advantage of the opportunities and prepare for the challenges these technologies will present. While Canada has an active Science and Technology Strategy(link is external) to support technological innovation and training, deeper exploration of the parallel social and economic challenges resulting from these innovations would be useful to help government, business and society prepare.
This study builds on the analysis of digital technologies in MetaScan 2. Digital technologies provide the platform that enables rapid diffusion and integration of the other three technologies. MetaScan 2 highlighted a number of challenges: The emergence of all-digital supply chains may challenge the tools and notion of a "national economy." The rise of virtual foreign workers who use online tools to work across national boundaries will expand job opportunities for Canadians and possibly change immigration patterns and diversify trade in high- and low-skilled services. The need for just-in-time skills development and reputation systems to track workers' competence will challenge the educational system. Firms will increasingly be virtual, international, project-oriented networks drawing on skilled workers wherever they live. What policies, programs and infrastructure would enable individuals and firms to thrive in this highly competitive environment?
- The new technologies increase productivity but with fewer workers. The next decade could be a period of jobless growth.
- All sectors of the economy will be under pressure to adapt or exploit the new technologies. The main features of the shift include greater customization, localization and intelligence built into production and delivery. Having people with the right skills will be essential.
- Shifting competitive advantage. Synthetic biology is the technology with the greatest potential for surprise. It could make it easier for Canada's customers to grow their own fuel, food and natural resources. It may also make it easier for Canada to grow products like biosteel. The transition will not happen overnight, but Canadians should assess the long-term impact of this technology on key sectors and, if appropriate, develop strategies to move Canada up the value chain.
- A growing number of jobs will be temporary or non-standard jobs. For years, temporary work has been one of the fastest-growing employment groups. Interestingly, temporary and freelance jobs are an essential and growing part of the emerging economy. A core opportunity is to help them be more productive. They are outside the current social contract, so freelancers may not get the support they need to develop and prosper.
- The end of privacy as we know it. Several of the technologies will combine to make it easier and cheaper to learn about one another. There are huge personal and societal benefits to be gained when personal data is merged in large databases in areas like health care, but traditional notions of privacy may be challenged.
- New patterns of inequality may emerge. Technological advance may help generate better opportunities for individuals, but may also create new barriers to access. For example, several technologies offer new ways to assist the injured and the disabled, but the cost of treatment could limit access and create new inequities.
- Infrastructure in transition. The new technologies will likely drive significant change in infrastructure for health, transportation, security and energy systems. The challenge will be determining whether to maintain the old infrastructure or leapfrog to the new, more efficient one.
- Strengthening risk management and regulatory systems. All of the four groups of technologies will put increasing pressure on current risk management and regulatory systems in new ways. The global nature of these technologies suggests it will be challenging to respond quickly and in collaboration with other countries.
- Building a national culture of innovation. This is an era of considerable opportunity. The four groups of technologies in this study are laying the foundation for the next 50 years of development. With the right information, skills and policies at every level – from the individual to the global – Canada can prosper. Canada needs to see the whole innovation ecosystem and develop policies to support adaptation, experimentation, skills development, regulation and entrepreneurship.
This report takes the reader through a thought process that will help them examine or build their own mental model about how these technologies could shape the Canadian economy and society. The Horizons foresight method (see Appendix 2) does not predict the future. Rather, it systematically explores a range of futures and identifies plausible surprises and challenges that may emerge over the next 10 to 15 years. The objective of this study is to encourage dialogue and debate on core assumptions and emerging challenges to help develop robust policies and strategies to address them.
The icons – for video links, for where to find additional information and for "weak signals" – are intended to help you "see" signs of change in the present. Reading this report online will allow you to view this information. Pages 4-8 will help you visualize the technologies that will drive change. Pages 9-19 explore how those drivers could shape 10 "domains," including manufacturing, services, resources, health, transportation and security. The domains illustrate the potential for change by providing examples of what our lives could be like in 2025. Pages 20-26 extend the analysis and describe the policy challenges that Canada may confront over the next 10 to 15 years. Pages 27-28 outline new assumptions that may be useful in shaping public policy.
These technologies will drive changes that will shape the economy and society over the next 15 years.
In a world of causes and effects, change drivers are developments that significantly alter the system under study.
Many environmental scans focus on change drivers and their implications. In a foresight study, surprises and challenges emerge as the change drivers interact with each other and the system under study.
Our understanding of biology is growing and the impact is potentially enormous. Dr. Freeman Dyson,perhaps one of the most influential voices of the science landscape in the recent past, has stated, "the domestication of biotechnology will dominate our lives during the next fifty years at least as much as the domestication of computers has dominated our lives during the previous fifty years." This section examines several of the emerging biotechnologies that will drive social and economic change.
Synthetic biology may be the least known and most "disruptive" of the technologies in this study. In essence, it is the application of engineering principles to biology. It draws on a number of existing technologies to design and construct new biological systems that produce useful products or serve useful purposes. Current software helps bio-engineers use a growing online library of "biobricks" to design new genetic functions. Biobricks can be assembled by robots, or digital DNA files can be sent to a DNA printer; in either case, the new DNA is inserted into a living cell. The technology is proving to be very efficient. For example, when genetic engineering (which modifies only a few genes at a time) was used to develop a yeast to produce precursors to the antimalarial drug, artemisinin(link is external), it took 150 person-years of work and $25 million. Using biobricks, however, a lab of 12 people produced 12 biological systems of comparable complexity in 3 months. Working in this field is becoming easier for researchers at all levels. In 2013, the International Genetically Engineered Machines(link is external) competition (iGEM) hosted over 200 university and 30 high school teams in using the new technologies to design and build new biological systems. There are clearly risks and opportunities. There are concerns about the safety of creating new life – particularly in the absence of a well-tested regulatory framework. On the opportunity side, life replicates itself for free, input costs are low, and manufacturing more biological devices involves only using more feedstock. Progress in synthetic biology could mean the beginning of a different world that moderates today's concerns over issues like resource depletion and energy supply.
Bioinformatics involves storing, analyzing, modeling and sharing large amounts of biological data. Current applications of bioinformatics include DNA barcoding, new bioproducts (such as Millennium Asparagus and biodiesel(link is external)), modeling disease outbreaks and personal genomics. Our capacity to analyze large amounts of data and our ability to affect traits in plants, animals and humans will increase dramatically. Consider the potential of a widespread medical device costing under $1,000 that sequences your genome, connects to online databases, profiles your genetic history and future, highlights your risk profile, and identifies opportunities to mitigate risks. Bioinformatics holds the promise of tailoring medical and drug treatments to the individual through preventative medicine, using biomarkers to model adverse drug reactions, and helping to understand the complex interplay between genetics and environment. Bioinformatics will fundamentally change the way we think of and deliver health care systems.
Tissue engineering uses synthetic or naturally grown biomaterials to replace damaged or defective tissues, such as bone, skin and even entire organs. Today, organs that can be regrown include skin, windpipes and bladders; in a decade, this list may expand to kidneys, livers and hearts. Stem cells may also be used to repair damaged or failing organs in place. The most immediate application for tissue engineering is in the area of human health for purposes of healing, replacement and augmentation. This technology will reduce the need for organ donation and eliminate transplant rejection as body parts are regrown or printed using the patient's own cells. In the longer term, advances in skin, bone and muscle synthesis may even allow individuals to change their appearance and augment physical abilities.
Even as our understanding of life grows, new opportunities are emerging at an even smaller scale. Nano is derived from the Greek word "nanos," which means "dwarf," and it refers to the fact that nanoscience operates at an atomic scale. At this scale, substances sometimes behave in novel ways. This field is less advanced than biotechnologies, although much of current nanotechnology has a large biotechnology component. Some say that nanotechnology will be "technology on steroids" as it will improve or speed up developments across many technologies.
Nano-scale systems often exhibit properties that improve upon or are much different from their humanscale varieties; for example, silver exhibits anti-bacterial properties at the nano-scale that are absent at the macro-scale. As scientists work with materials close to the molecular level, they can produce new and useful materials, such as nanocellulose(link is external) and nanocarbon(link is external). Both have impressive performance characteristics, being respectively 10 and 50 times stronger than steel for their weight. Nanocoatings provide new ways to make structures self-cleaning, more durable and perhaps even able to receive, store and respond to stimuli. Other nanomaterials are excellent catalysts for making chemistry greener and cheaper. Over the next 15 years, nanomaterials will change the types of things we build and how we build them.
Nanodevices and nanosensors
Nanodevices are machines made of a number of molecular parts that do useful work (such as moving or changing electrically, chemically or optically) in response to specific inputs. Examples include nanoelectromechanical systems (NEMS), nanosensors, nanocomputers and nanorobots. They have surprising energy-efficiency, power density, sensitivity and optical efficiency. Their small size also reduces production costs and increases the number of devices running in parallel, increasing speed. They are likely to be of most use in medical devices, although their small size may lead them to be treated as "smart" drugs. They are also likely to be components of human-scale devices to increase the performance or provide new abilities.
Nanosensors, in particular, are set to have a huge impact. They may open the door to the development of inexpensive, portable devices that can rapidly detect, identify and quantify biological and chemical substances. These may take the form of specific sensing devices, or may simply be features integrated into the next few generations of mobile phones. As such, nanosensors are expected to lead to revolutionary applications, including early disease detection, real-time health monitoring, the early and accurate detection of environmental pollutants and contaminants, and even biological or chemical weapons.
Nanotechnology for Energy
Nanotechnology may improve energy systems in two key areas over the next 15 years. First, solar cells, cheaper now than they have ever been, are poised for significant improvement due largely to nanotechnology. High-efficiency multi-junction solar cells(link is external), infrared energy capture(link is external) and wavelength-splitting(link is external) designs may increase high-efficiency solar cell performance by 200-300%. Roll-to-roll printing(link is external) of solar cells on plastic using photosynthetic inks will allow solar panels to be manufactured at significantly lower costs than even today's low prices.
Secondly, batteries will improve through the use of enhanced nanomaterials and economies of scale. We expect higher capacities, much faster recharging, and greater longevity and significantly lower prices. Better and cheaper batteries could be the cornerstone technology to displace the internal combustion engine for passenger vehicles and support the transition to renewables in homes and businesses by addressing the intermittency of renewable energy sources like wind and solar. Using these technologies, buildings may become energy independent and solar-powered fueling stations could support the growing electric vehicle market.
Neuroscience is the study of the structure and function of the nervous system and brain. Advances in neuro- and cognitive science have improved our understanding of perception, memory, reasoning and emotion. This field is a little less advanced than the previous two but, given recent massive investments in the U.S. and E.U., there is significant potential for surprise in the next 15 years.
Neurostimulation covers those technologies that stimulate, or block, certain parts of the nervous system, particularly within the brain. The technology is used to treat various severe neurological disorders, such as Parkinson's disease, depression and insomnia. Neurostimulation can also be used to augment human cognitive function. Neurostimulation has historically been performed through both invasive (surgery) and non-invasive means (taking pills, electrical stimulation). Wearable headsets are now being marketed that work by adding a slight voltage to neurons, letting them fire more easily. These devices use transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS)(link is external), which has the potential to enhance language, learning, attention, problem solving, coordination and memory functions; help combat insomnia, anxiety, and depression; and manage pain. The future use of both "smart drugs" and tDCS could allow some people to gain a competitive advantage over others.
A brain-computer interface (BCI) is a direct communication pathway that connects nerve signals in the brain to an external computer. BCIs can be invasive (implanted within or just above the brain), or noninvasive (on the scalp surface). BCIs are used therapeutically to assist, augment or repair human cognitive, sensory or motor functions. Today, it requires training and practice to make BCIs useful and reliable. Research, artificial intelligence and more data, however, will improve this significantly. Potential near-term applications include the use of BCIs to detect lapses in attention among occupations requiring vigilance, and as a communication tool for those who have lost motor skills but retained cognition. In the future, this technology could be used to improve cognitive functions, to better understand human preferences, and to augment human capabilities such as coordination and response times. It may even be used to develop senses new to humans, such as the ability to sense magnetic fields, infrared light or radio waves.
The digital revolution is the most mature of the four technology groups in this study (see MetaScan 2 for a description of digital futures). Digital technologies and infrastructure provide a foundation that will integrate, network and accelerate the three groups of technologies described above.
Artificial intelligence (AI) involves giving machines such traits as reasoning, planning, learning, communication and perception, and the ability to move and manipulate objects. AI is in wide use today: in Apple's Siri(link is external) for voice recognition, Google's text and image search (link is external)functions, Facebook's facial recognition (link is external)capability, NASA's rovers(link is external), and algorithmic stock trading. Currently, however, AI is task-specific. The next step is for researchers and computer scientists to advance AI so that computers can learn general knowledge that can be used to enable them to work in new situations, or respond better to the user's contexts and mood. AI innovations are software-based, and are being incorporated into personal tools (e.g., smart phones, Google glasses) as new features, often at near-zero incremental cost. AI will make it possible to automate many tasks, greatly improving personal efficiency and productivity.
Robotics is the branch of technology that deals with the design, construction, operation and application of robots and related computer and control systems. Robots help with or take the place of humans in dangerous environments or manufacturing processes, and/or resemble humans in appearance, behaviour or cognition. Increasingly, robots are designed to act in roles complementary to humans. Today, experimental robots can inventory stock, move loads, pick berries, do housework, perform elder care, sense remotely and create a virtual presence. As their AI improves, they will get smarter and more capable. Robot hardware is improving quickly; the challenge is the software – the intelligence behind the machine that allows it to function in a specific manner. Task-specific robots could do tasks as diverse as surgery, cooking and driving. Businesses will continue to be early adopters of robot technology, with home use following as prices decline and features become more competitive.
This section illustrates the potential impacts the new technologies could have on ten "domains" within society. It explores four traditional economic domains – manufacturing, services, natural resources and agriculture – then four key infrastructure domains – health, energy, transportation and security – and finally two cross-cutting perspectives on what work and home could look like. It is not a prediction of the future, but rather is intended to help readers get a sense of what is possible if these technologies develop in ways that many experts think are plausible. There are opportunities and risks with each technology that will influence its development.
Manufacturing may be more local and efficient.
When it comes to light manufacturing, synthetic biology and 3D printing have similar characteristics: they both support the local production of a "product" from a digital file using simple low-cost equipment; they enable very low-cost replication of a small or large quantity; and they allow the user to easily experiment and customize the product. Currently, 3D printing uses close to 30 different materials with growing complexity (e.g., Boeing prints 22 000 different airline parts). Soon this will include clothes, many consumer goods and electronic gadgets, to name a few. Synthetic biology will likely produce liquids, solids and industrial chemicals for pharmaceuticals, medicine, paper and building supplies and other goods yet to be imagined, in small or large quantities, and may produce raw materials on-site for local manufacturing plants.
Low-cost robots may level robots may level the playing field.
Sensors, artificial intelligence and robots will reshape heavy manufacturing and are likely to have a leveling impact across both developed and developing economies. While developing countries may lose their low-cost labour advantage as advanced economies deploy an affordable AI-enabled robotic workforce, both economies will be able to deploy AI and increase the productivity of their low-skilled workers.
New materials with new materials with new properties may stimulate innovation.
New bio and nanomaterials are likely to launch a new era of product and process innovation. Their new properties are changing the size, at both ends of the scale, at which designers, engineers and architects can dream. Nanocomposites and other new materials – some as strong as steel and others soft and supple – will improve the performance of manufactured products and support a wider range of 3D printed objects. Embedded sensors and digital tags within materials will enable tracking along the supply chain, offering improved transparency and monitoring of product life cycles.
Industrial processes become more environmental.
Growing pressure on renewable and non-renewable resources, as well as public concern about the safety of new nano and biomaterials, will put greater emphasis on building "closed-loop systems." In these systems, waste from one industry becomes the feedstock for another. Products may be designed to be safe and fully recyclable. Synthetic biology will enable industrial processes to mimic nature (e.g., enzymes can accelerate the decomposition of industrial waste into safe by-products and have commercial value), and nanotechnology will produce new goods with new properties at a smaller scale that may use far less resources. (For example, soon, a smart phone will contain 20 or 30 tiny nanosensors that collect biometric data.)
Potential Policy Challenge:
- What are the risks for human health and the environment in using biotechnology and nanotechnology to produce goods? Are we able to mitigate these risks?
New kinds of services
The Canadian economy is dominated by the services sector, employing 78% of Canada's workforce in 2012. Emerging technologies are likely to increase productivity, but may displace labour in both high- and low-skilled service jobs. Whole new employment and service opportunities are likely to emerge in areas such as professional and business-to-business services; care for aging populations; health care; culture and recreation; intangible products (concepts, designs, information, advice); and international trade-in-services.
Services increasingly customized to the individual
Sensors and artificial intelligence (AI) in print media, signs, and devices will mean that services can be increasingly tailored to the users' interests by sensing their demographic information and recalling prior choices. Public spaces will be more interactive and able to offer pertinent information without the user navigating tedious menus. Repeat business is ensured by remembering past preferences. AI could remind a hairstylist how a person likes their hair cut, or what toppings they prefer at the burger joint. Means of gathering instant feedback around new experiences will also be useful; at the dentist, a brain-computer interface could verify the patient's level of comfort. AI tutors could offer students personal attention and "gamify" learning goals (apply game techniques) to encourage progress.
Virtual, augmented and remote services will change the geography of services.
It is likely that services typically conducted face-to-face will be increasingly performed online. Visits to a doctor or lawyer will likely start with a virtual pre-screening interview; the visit itself may also be virtual. In schools, each student may be equipped with a personal AI teacher who monitors their progress and advancement through content modules, with human teachers playing an oversight role. Augmented reality devices may enable travelers and tourists to explore, relax or do business without leaving home. "Telepresencing" (the sense of being in multiple locations at once) will allow users to choose the best service provider for their needs from anywhere in the world rather than the best one in their area.
Potential policy challenges:
- Will new technologies reduce or increase the job-creating potential of the service sector?
- Will there be a global consolidation as large, well-funded companies automate local and national services?
- How do we encourage the right entrepreneurial and technical skills among Canadians to create the next generation of service businesses
Sustainable resource management and harvesting
The new technologies – particularly sensors, data analytics, AI, drones, robots and synthetic biology – could usher in a new era for the sustainable management and harvesting of forest and fish resources. Together, these tools could allow resource managers and government overseers to monitor ecosystem and resource health, to develop more ecological planting and harvesting strategies, and to quickly identify and implement targeted interventions. Being able to see the whole system would improve planning, investment and public accountability.
Robots for traditional and undersea resource acquisition
Drones and robots will play a growing role in prospecting and extracting in both traditional and undersea mining, particularly in situations that are remote, difficult or dangerous. The operators of these robots may live in urban locations with their families and never set foot on-site. Operators could live in different time zones around the world, enabling round-the-clock production without major disruptions to their personal and family lives.
Bioproduction of raw materials
Synthetic biology uses genetically engineered organisms to manufacture a growing range of materials such as bioplastics, biofuels, biorubber, biosteel, spider silk and industrial chemicals. Industries that may be disrupted include pulp and paper, building materials, chemical manufacturing, pharmaceuticals, agriculture and fossil fuel extraction. Secondary-processing companies could bypass the primary producers and develop self-sufficient factories that grow raw materials to their exact specifications using bioreactors and locally available feedstock. As this field develops, it may be hard for traditional producers to remain competitive.
Potential policy challenges:
- What impact could synthetic biology have on the global market for Canada's resources in the next 15 years?
In 2028, synthetic biology will have the potential to produce different kinds of food, including meat and drinks at lower costs than today. By manipulating genes, brand-new foods can be created with new properties or flavours. The bioproduction industry is expected to reach $100 billion by 2020 alone. This technology, which uses glass or plastic vats (bioreactors), and needs only sun or sugar, algae and nutrients, can be located anywhere.
More robust, genetically modified crops
Synthetic biology can also be used to develop new crops with desirable traits such as salt-tolerance, drought-tolerance, and pest-resistance. This technology may help address issues raised by climate change or relieve pressure on arable land, particularly that used to grow feed for animals and some food crops (e.g., sugar, corn for fuel).
Robots on the farm
Farming has the potential to become far more resource-efficient and environmentally friendly on existing farmland, given the prospects for greater automation using AI, robotics and sensors. Flying drones could monitor large fields more quickly and precisely. With information from these drones, as well as that provided by satellites and sensors, automated tractors and sprayers could apply water, seeds, pesticides and nutrients in more targeted and timely ways. This precision could further be enhanced through nanomaterial-based, slow-release pesticides and insecticides. Robotic pickers will continue to emerge and, in time, be able to harvest more types of crops. Automated agriculture could make indoor agriculture more viable in regions where the impact of climate change is degrading arable land, food supply and reliability.
Tracing food from seed to mouth
Food-related information for monitoring regulations and markets could be enhanced through implanted chips, sensors and bioinformatics. We may be able to trace food production as well as the path of food-borne diseases to a much higher degree. Markets, consumers and governments could have much more detailed knowledge of where food comes from, who produced it, how, and with what by-products.
Potential policy challenges:
Public support for genetically modified foods remains uncertain. What risks are involved with synthetic biology?
Automated smart farms may have a reduced need for traditional labour, but may require farmers with new skills who can take advantage of the new technologies.
Could these technologies help unlock new potential in remote areas in Canada?
Solar and wind may become cost-effective
Recently, there have been significant improvements in both solar and wind technologies, including cheap printing processes for solar panels. Many science sources suggest that solar and wind energy may become the most cost effective choice for new electricity generation in many locations within 15 years. As solar and wind have become more affordable, massive research and venture capital has been going into battery storage for homes, buildings and vehicles. Effective and economical battery storage is on the horizon. It is the key enabling technology to ensure that buildings using renewable energy are powered during cloudy and windless days.
Decentralized energy systems
The combination of cost-effective solar, wind and battery technologies are the key building blocks for decentralized energy systems. Buildings could plug into the grid or operate independently. Electric cars could be plugged into buildings where they could act as a supplementary power source.
More electric and hybrid vehicles
Electric engines will grow in the auto sector as advanced batteries take off. Initial costs of electric vehicles are foreseen to decline to parity with conventional vehicles as battery production rises twentyfold. The cost of ownership of electric vehicles is a quarter of the cost of those with internal combustion engines, which will further promote the adoption of electric vehicles as parity approaches. Advanced hybrid engines using biofuels may create a new market segment.
Bioreactors using algae modified through synthetic biology will likely allow firms to produce cheap fuels that use only sunlight and waste CO2 and water as inputs. Production costs for diesel and ethanol through this "green chemistry" could reach $0.30/L in sunny geographies. Since CO2could become a valuable commodity as an input for bioreactors, carbon-emitting facilities might diversify into green manufacturing plants. Greener ways to process the oil sands are possible.
Potential policy challenges
- Are we transitioning from centralized to decentralized energy systems? What is the right balance? What does it mean for investment and research?
- Could countries, regions or companies that embrace decentralized energy systems have a longterm competitive advantage? Lower costs? More resilience?
The arrival of autonomous and semi-autonomous vehicles
The transportation system is in transition. As old vehicles are replaced, the new ones will be more autonomous, smarter and more efficient. Autonomous wheelchairs and delivery vehicles, for example, may become available in hospitals, factories, warehouses and resorts. Although not yet fully autonomous, vehicles with "driver assist" are the new standard for public and personal transportation. Diagnostic tools that use AI will enable vehicles to service themselves by seeking oil changes, brake servicing – even cleaning. As vehicles become even more autonomous, their interiors may transform, allowing passengers to comfortably work or play while they move from place to place. And cars will sync with other devices (e.g., phone, computer, refrigerator) to simplify life even more. Accidents could still occur but identifying who is to blame (the manufacturer, the car's AI designer or the owner) will become a challenge. All of these factors will contribute to new notions of vehicle ownership and liability.
The internet of "moving" things
It's not just vehicles; the transportation system itself may also transform. AI in cars and trucks will benefit from highway – and eventually city – roads that include sensors, reflectors, information transmitters and other tools that support autonomous vehicles. Although not all vehicles will be fully autonomous, the majority will at least be "linked" with each other and with traffic control systems to facilitate coordination and communication. This will greatly improve the efficiency of the system, allowing vehicles to move more quickly and, in some areas, travel in a highly coordinated manner that minimizes gridlock. But privacy could be an emerging issue, since all vehicles may now be monitored, mapped – and possibly even controlled – remotely. Trucking and rail transportation methods will continue to compete. Lighter rail cars and the availability of biodiesel means rail may compete more strongly with trucking; however, automated caravans of trucks equipped with sensors will increase the efficiency of the trucking system and reduce costs.
Moving from gasoline engines to hybrids and electric
The power behind transportation is changing. Both electric and hybrid engines will become more common. Energy exchanges between homes and cars using smart grids and "smart homes" technologies will become possible. Fossil fuels may be supplemented with diesel or bioethanol produced locally in bioreactors. The use of light, strong nanomaterials, including nanocarbon, in conjunction with more efficient and longerrange engines and batteries, means vehicles will be safer, weigh less and go farther. The availability of stronger and more heat-tolerant nanomaterials may allow higher running temperatures and more energy-efficient engines. Regardless of mode (airplane, rail, ship or personal car), vehicle range will likely increase, operating costs will drop and environmental impacts will decrease.
Enhanced delivery systems
The transportation portion of industrial value chains will be dramatically more efficient, timely and automated. AI and robotic loading equipment will coordinate the movement of goods between transportation modes and systems, a factor that may foster a more competitive domestic manufacturing sector and keeps costs low. Lean and efficient business models characterized by "just-in-time" systems means responsive production and delivery of goods. For smaller deliveries, some vehicles may be displaced by programmable flying drones that can carry small packages between local destinations. These changes will have an impact on employment and on the sector's overall contribution to gross domestic product.
Potential policy challenges
- Are governments ready to accommodate new forms of vehicle ownership and liability?
- As the availability of new technologies creates new demands, how will governments manage costs for upgrading or replacing infrastructure?
- The emerging transportation system is built on an extensive data-sharing network. What could this mean for privacy?
Sequencing patient DNA may lead to personalized medicine
DNA data will help medical professionals better identify drug treatments that are effective and safe for a particular patient, and at dosages suitable for their metabolism. Personalized drug testing on stem cells cloned from the patient could reduce the need for more general animal and human drug trials and possibly identify a wider range of possible treatments. As the genetic markers of disease become increasingly known, DNA will grow more useful in diagnosis, as well as pre-diagnosis – offering risk profiles of conditions well before the onset of symptoms. Some chronic diseases may be prevented or even eradicated through prenatal interventions, early-life treatments, or possibly gene therapy.
Genomics, nanotechnology and synthetic biology could create prevention solutions
Beyond the predictive benefits of personalized medicine, nano-driven sensors are offering earlier detection (e.g., needing fewer cells to spot cancer). These sensors will be paired with therapeutics to support early intervention, such as theranostics(link is external). Nanotechnology and synthetic biology may alleviate concerns about growing antibiotic resistance through solutions to reduce the spread of bacteria or, more effectively, destroy it. Viral outbreaks are already being successfully contained by analyzing an individual's DNA to detect pathogens. In the future, sensors and electronic records will facilitate this tracking, while synthetic biology may have a role in formulating just-in-time vaccines.
Health monitoring will move beyond the clinical setting, closer to you
Health sensors will appear more frequently in everyday items such as mobile phones or toilets, wearables (e.g., clothing, jewelry – even skin); in a multifunctional "tricorder" (hand-held diagnostic device); or as part of a "lab-on-a-chip" that people may soon keep in their medicine cabinets. The process for self-monitoring of health indicators, as well as monitoring of healthy or unhealthy behaviours, will be simpler and more routine. When diagnostic data is networked, AI-augmented and relayed to clinicians, round-the-clock remote care becomes possible. As brain-computer interface (BCI) tools bring greater awareness of mental states, the brain-body connection underlying addictions, illness and treatment will present new options (e.g., neurostimulation, neuro-enhancing drugs, or simply behaviour change).
Regeneration of lost or diseased tissue
Organ donor wait-lists and black market organ trading may be things of the past for all but the most complicated organs, such as the heart. Growing or 3D printing of organs from a patient's own cells will allow for faster recovery without rejection. Even nerve damage may become surmountable with the assistance of BCI and robotics. As a consequence, we should anticipate that the line between natural versus enhanced human capability will blur.
Potential policy challenges
- Can we use these new technologies to design systems that reduce public health care costs?
- What changes in institutions, roles and responsibilities are needed to ensure oversight, safety, equity, effectiveness and accountability?
- As some diseases become preventable and new means of extending life and ability are adopted, the views of Canadians around costs, access and rights are likely to be very controversial.
Slow shift in the types of resources that are scarce, and the areas that are at risk
Resource scarcity is a potential source of conflict. Advances in synthetic biology could reduce pressure on some scarce natural resources by increasing the security of energy, material and food sources. In parallel, new and different minerals may become scarce. For example, lithium reserves may come under pressure as the demand for batteries grows. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change anticipates that food and water scarcity driven by climate change will be a growing issue and a potential source of conflict and population displacement. Cheaper solar energy would lower the cost of desalination, which could increase food production and reduce the number of refugees forced to leave some drought-prone food-growing areas. This could be bolstered by the development of hardier crops and more adaptive farming methods using new technologies.
Open-source warefare grows
"Do-it-yourself" surveillance and weapon systems will likely become more common, enabling new kinds of crimes and conflict. For example, the Switchblade Drone is lethal at short distances and fits in a small backpack. New developments in sensors, robotics and nanotechnology could lead to the more widespread use of remote sensors in surveillance, intelligence and warfare. Miniature unmanned aerial, surface and aquatic vehicles and devices – controlled either remotely or autonomously – are expected to become more prevalent. These will be smaller, cheaper and more widely available than today. Open-source knowledge may lead to widely distributed cyber-warfare capabilities. In addition, do-it-yourself enthusiasts may use synthetic biology to produce and release harmful substances into the environment – either accidentally or on purpose. In all these cases, technology originally created to enhance security may become the threat. In response, pre-programmed nanodevices and robots will likely create security networks and sensing surfaces that could identify threats such as nano-enabled weapons, viruses and poisons.
The end of public anonymity
Constant monitoring and surveillance will become increasingly prevalent through the use of nano and biosensors, brain-computer interfaces, and artificial intelligence (AI). Smart devices will routinely know a person's movements and location to within 10 centimetres, which will make it possible to infer a person's activity, behaviour, interactions and relationships. This will make it increasingly difficult for individuals to go unnoticed, as AI can identify people from face and gait, and even determine the behaviour patterns of those without smart devices by looking at those who do. These devices will increasingly be used to identify, authenticate and track the movement of food, goods and materials in value chains. Constant monitoring and surveillance could also enhance public health and environmental and personal security. For example, in emergency situations, sensors, AI and machine-to-machine communication could make it easier to locate people and identify their needs. As privacy becomes a major issue, there may be a need to rethink the balance between public and private interests and liberties.
Potential policy challenges
- How can we prepare for the spread of cheap – but lethal – do-it-yourself weapon systems?
- As environmental sensors and security-monitoring systems grow, what new rules, roles and responsibilities will arise between the various government, business and non-government watchdogs to share information in the face of a bio-crisis or terrorist attack?
Home is where the "brain" is
The "internet of things(link is external)" will have considerable impact on homes, but at its core will be the need to make sense of all the information being generated. Homes will be able to combine, interpret and relay the information coming in from a variety of new sensors in appliances, fixtures and fittings, information that ranges from specific needs and monitoring of occupants, to basic system diagnostics. Artificial intelligence (AI) and the "internet of things" will move us from the age of the home computer to the age of the "computer home."
Interaction will change
New technologies will allow traditional in-home activities to also happen virtually. The seamless management of data and systems, enabled by AI and new materials, will change how homes look. It is likely that new interactive surfaces will appear throughout the home that will allow occupants to monitor and manage household systems and communicate with others. Over time, as technology evolves, traditional building materials and fittings will be displaced by new ones that will integrate with a home's AI and sensors. These sensors will share information remotely with smart phones and smart vehicles, allowing people to administer their house remotely.
Where does private end and public begin?
By allowing coordination with systems outside the home, the line between home and work and between public and private will continue to blur. Home systems that sync with external systems (such those at work or school) will allow occupants to work, learn and relax in one locale. But such systems could also sync with neighbourhoods, regions, municipalities, utilities and more to support decision-making about land-use planning, infrastructure, health outcomes and development.
The construction of 3D-printed homes
Innovations in robotics, AI and building materials may change both the look and the construction of new homes. The advent of large-scale 3D printing means that homes could be built more rapidly and with nano-enhanced materials, making them even stronger and more energy-efficient than they are now. It could also mean lower costs and greater flexibility in home and urban design.
The autonomous home
The trend toward decentralization of energy and other infrastructure will make homes more autonomous, but will make the need for coordination among systems even more crucial. Distributed energy systems will result in homes that can both contribute to and draw from the grid, but such innovations will be dependent on advances in energy production and storage. Unconstrained by traditional urban services, new homes could proliferate in areas well beyond urban planning control.
Potential policy challenges
- Will there be equity issues among those who are in a position to "keep up" and those who can't?
- How will the information gathered by the internet of things be used? Who should have access?
- Who will ensure interoperability among systems? How will infrastructure need to change?
Fewer, but more productive, workers
Artificial intelligence (AI), sensors, data analytics and robots will drive significant change in many workplaces in Canada and around the world. These technologies will transform many jobs where a routine physical or mental task is repeated; AI will increasingly handle the routine, while workers will be free to focus on the exceptions that AI cannot handle. AI and data analytics will also increase productivity and the demand for non-routine and professional skills by reframing the way we design, coordinate, manage, deliver and assess products and services. Sensors will provide workers with a much broader picture of the processes they manage, improving efficiency and client satisfaction. Cheaper, mass-produced robots and autonomous delivery vehicles will change the flow, timing and flexibility of work. Working conditions and on-the-job safety will greatly improve for dangerous professions, largely through the use of sensors, drones and robots in fields such as mining, policing and rescue missions.
More contract and part-time workers
As noted in MetaScan 2, more and more workers will likely be part-time, self-employed contactors in the emerging "project economy." For the duration of a project, they may work in an office, in their home or from a creative hub or public space. Smart surfaces will enable workers to create or share a workspace anywhere, with capacity for virtual face-to-face and group-to-group collaboration. Both high- and low-skilled workers will do tasks or jobs of varying duration for multiple employers, brokered through social media and "microtasking" apps.
Growing number of international "virtual workers."
The same tools that allow Canadians to work from a coffee shop will also support them in becoming "virtual workers" for employers in other countries. If they develop the right skills, they could compete globally for short tasks or part-time or full-time work. The system will also allow foreigners to bid for tasks and jobs in Canada. The workforce will become increasingly global. Worksites are emerging that facilitate finding virtual work (e.g., freelancer.ca(link is external) or eLance.com(link is external)). Reputation systems (e.g., eBay's ratings system) will track individual performance, competence and specific skills to allow virtual employers to quickly find competent and trustworthy workers.
New organizational structures
The new technologies, new work arrangements and other global change drivers are likely to generate new kinds of organizations. For instance, one can imagine a service corporation where all of the services are provided by AI with fewer human employees. A growing number of modern corporations will have a small management team that contracts out all functions through the entire product life cycle. It is possible that unorganized skilled workers will find people with complementary skills and create informal, temporary teams to take advantage of an opportunity to work together virtually to deliver a good or service.
Potential policy challenges
- What are the emerging social and equity issues if there are fewer traditional jobs?
- Are there infrastructure, institutional or policy changes that will give virtual workers a competitive advantage?
- What is the role of national governments in the regulation and oversight of virtual work and temporary virtual organizations?
Illustrative domain narratives
Grow your own
Samantha was shocked to find out her route had been cancelled. She had been hauling steel from the shipyard to the fabrication plant for over 20 years. She liked the ocean view and fresh air. The company she worked for imported steel and turned it into rebar for the construction industry.
Samantha slammed her truck door and quickly made her way to find her boss to express her frustration. She hesitated as she saw Douglas in the break room.
“What’s this about them cancelling my run to the shipyard?”
“We don’t need steel anymore,” answered Douglas. “Apparently, we’re going to grow our own steel on site… Read the memo.’’ Douglas pointed in the direction of the wall screens.
Samantha read the news wall. The on-site process would use biological feedstock, enzymes and heat from the neighbouring waste-management facility to grow bio-steel in rebar molds, plus a whole new line of other construction products. The resulting material would be certified as a renewable product. Samantha wondered if she still had a job.
Douglas noticed her troubled look. He said the feedstock would be coming from local forests and agricultural sites and asked whether she would mind a new route in the country? Samantha’s mood lightened as she considered the new changes.
Don't smile at the screens
Kyle took a deep breath. This time he was going to do it. He walked right up to the cafeteria table where the pretty new student was sitting. “Excuse me,” he said, “but I just have to ask you something.”
“Yes?” She responded. He couldn’t place her accent.
“You always get the iced cappuccino with your food, but you never drink it.” The tall beverage container was sitting unopened next to her laptop.
She looked embarrassed. “They . . . they always just serve it to me when I get in line. I tried one the first day and now they seem to think that’s what I always want.”
“Oh! I can tell you how to stop that if you’d like.” Soon, Kyle was immersed in showing the girl, who told him her name was Mia, how to navigate the Canadian services industry.
“Don’t smile at the screens; they’ll assume you like what they’re doing and do more of it. Don’t make eye contact with the people in the posters—they’re not static pictures, you know, they’re actually cameras, watching us to see what we’re buying. They’re constantly profiling us.”
“The storm’s not that bad, Martha! We can ride it out.”
Outside the windows of Martha Bowen’s rock-steady apartment in Regina, the day was sunny and calm, but the image on her monitor showed her colleague Jacob was rocking ominously on the surface of Hudson Bay.
“I’m sure you’re safe, Jacob, but the mining bots are another matter,” she said. Martha was the head of her company’s equipment maintenance department and the safety of the rare earth mining bots was her responsibility. The entire company employed dozens of employees and hundreds of robots, but only a handful of on-site personnel like Jacob. Most of her colleagues, from a dozen different nations, worked from home.
Another window on her screen showed the operators of the mining robots driving their drones to docking stations below. As one of the drones was readying itself to dock, a wave shoved it hard against the docking lock mechanism. The mining drone was tough—she saw it bounce away undamaged—but the locking mechanism exploded. Nanosensors embedded within the part immediately sent a damage report to Martha.
“Did you see that?” Jacob stood up and stepped unsteadily to the window of the mining platform to look out. “Don’t worry,” Martha said, “it’s already taken care of.” The artificial intelligence managing the repair center had recognized the urgency of replacing the docking mechanism and immediately redirected the 3D printer to meet the new need. “Jacob, a replacement part will be ready within eight minutes.”
Her stomach churned as she watched Jacob and his small team batten down the hatches. Within minutes, he launched a repair drone armed with the new part into the frigid waters. She trusted Jacob and his team would be safe and, for now, her own job was done.
From green to gold
John’s small business strategy and finance advisor stared at him in disbelief. “Let me get this straight. Your business is on the brink of bankruptcy—”
“I’ll get back on track,” interrupted John. “Hurricane season was unusually bad this year. It will be better next year.”
“—and you’re asking for a loan to purchase . . . ” the advisor continued, looking at the file open on his tablet, “robotic strawberry pickers, nurturing drones and . . . nanodevices?”
“They deliver the right amount of water, nutrients and fertilizers. It’s called precision farming,” said John.
“I’m sorry, John,” said the advisor, shaking his head. It was true some farmers were having success with robots that could pick individual fruits. The resulting harvests were large, the crops were organic and the customers loved the idea. But it hadn’t been tried on the East Coast yet.
“Okay then,” said John, switching gears. “What if I got into biofuels? Forget about corn, I’m talking about algae. Bioreactors!”
The advisor whizzed around in his chair to face the bay window overlooking Halifax Harbour. He drummed his fingers on the arms of his chair. “Bioreactors have proven their worth. And they can make more than just ethanol. For a business like yours, finding a good niche market is the way to go.
“You should look into the bioproduction of enzymes for cleaning up oil spills. I think I can get the bank to grant you a loan for bioreactors. The digital files for the enzymes are free on the Creative Commons web site, and there is a government program that can provide you with some S&T advice. The program also includes a few practical, online micro-skill courses that will help fill in your knowledge gaps.”
The two men shook hands. John was beaming as he considered his new world of opportunities.
The quick change
Ferris was just biting into a peanut butter sandwich in the kitchen when he glanced at his home’s status panel and nearly choked. The house’s charge indicator showed it was full. It shouldn’t be, and this could mean only one thing: he’d forgotten to plug in the car—again.
Ferris decided he could wait around for the car to charge and apologize to his dad for the delay—they were supposed to go into the city together—or he could do something about it. Why not? He’d been meaning to update his home’s operating system anyway. The update, which was supposed to include a fast-charge option, usually required a technician to visit, but Ferris thought he could do it himself. He bent over the little wall-screen.
Since they had redone the entire roof with multi-spectrum solar shingles that were an astonishing 40 percent efficient, the house provided lots of power. Ferris had watched the roofers connect the system to the metal-air battery pack that sat outside next to the air conditioner. After the installation, he’d been fascinated to watch the power meter run backwards as the house fed electricity into the city’s grid rather than pulling it out.
A few minutes later, he had the operating system installed. As promised, there was a quick-charge option. After running outside to plug in the car, he tapped the screen to start the charge cycle. “Ha!” he said, feeling very proud of himself.
Fifteen minutes later, Ferris looked out the window to see his dad stepping out of a cab and walking toward the house. Just then, a notice popped up on the wall-screen telling him the car battery was now full.
Mode and destination, please
With her free hand, Monica pressed the lever that disconnected her minivan from the charging dock. Distressed by her daughter Willow’s coughing fit, Monica soothed the baby while buckling her into the integrated car seat. As she moved toward the driver’s seat, the vehicle’s AI addressed her. “Mode and destination, please.” Monica responded quickly, “Full autonomy, priority: Children’s Hospital.” There was a pause. “Please put on your seatbelt and secure loose articles. Expected time of arrival is 13 minutes given current road conditions. Check dashboard display to verify route.”
As the minivan backed up, Willow coughed again. Monica released the lever at the base of the driver’s seat, allowing it to rotate 180 degrees. She loosened Willow’s jacket and looked at the baby’s flushed cheeks. She called 911. “My baby is ill and I can’t get the fever under control. She seems to be having trouble breathing.”
“According to my screen, you are already on your way to the Children’s Hospital. Is that correct?”
“Yes.” The van was already merging onto the highway, seamlessly integrating with the traffic.
“Ms. Clark, since you are already on route, and the van is confirmed as a priority, I’m going to transfer your call to the triage desk at the Children’s Hospital.” Monica used her phone to share biometric data and expedite triage desk processes.
Monica looked up and, for the first time, noticed that other cars were moving to let her pass as her vehicle communicated the nature of her trip to others. The hospital came into view and she breathed a sigh of relief.
As the door slid open, an orderly poked his head in. “Ms. Clark? I’m Mark. Let’s get Willow in to see a doctor.” As Monica climbed from the vehicle, she turned and said, “Park and charge.” The doors slid shut and the van moved off to a charging station.
My BCI hat
Kumar looked at the words on the screen and hesitated, wondering if this health program sign-up was really any different than the many other programs in which he was enrolled.
He was already sharing a large amount of personal data. His smart wristband, for instance, collected loads of biometric information around the clock and then shared it with his doctor, his fitness community and his affiliated companies. While this was intrusive at times, he was able to customize the feedback to gain what he really wanted: better sleep, more energy and closer monitoring of his blood-sugar levels.
His bathroom mirror’s daily biometric report brought all his sensor information together where he could consider different lifestyle options and learn from professionals and others in the community. So far, that had worked well.
Kumar considered himself pretty modern in his habits, but his employer was even more forward-looking. Now that his employment probation period was complete, today Kumar was being outfitted with his own brain-computer interface (BCI) hat and was being offered the option to join the company’s pilot wellness program.
Now, his personal health game would involve new players: his employer and its drug plan, government sponsors and some businesses. It would connect more data and offer new incentives, all purportedly intended for healthier living.
It wasn’t as if his company wasn’t already monitoring his health. On one occasion, the security door at his workplace had stopped him from entering when it detected early signs of the flu—before it had even occurred to him to run a breath check on his home tricorder. If there was only one prescribed route to good health, it certainly wasn’t clear in this workplace. What was evident, though, was that these people were setting goals and living well by them.
He wanted in. He blinked twice at the screen, then raised his hand to touch the “Enrol Now” icon. Click.
Blue jay to the rescue
The eastern sky was turning silver as Jasmine slipped down the steps of her apartment and, at random, turned left. This was a pretty rundown neighbourhood, with a maze of identical row houses cut by overpasses. There would be plenty of staggering drunks about, some dangerous, so Jasmine tuned her eye-phones to the Blue Jay system and called up a safety overlay. Through her augmented reality glasses, the approaching intersection glowed faintly green in two directions, orange in another. She hurried a bit, turned onto a green street, and slowed to a stroll.
Somewhere down that orange street, someone was behaving suspiciously. She’d spotted a single Blue Jay—a small, sky-coloured drone—hovering at the intersection.
Using tools like gait analysis, the Jays could look at a crowd loitering at the metro and pick out the one person who was considering jumping in front of a train. They could distinguish between the man in the parking lot who was looking for his car, and the one who was looking to jack somebody else’s. They weren’t equipped with facial recognition software, but they painted the cityscape with colours so that all users of the free Blue Jay apps could be aware of the local security situation. If they detected something like a break-in in action, they would swarm the area and photograph every second of the event, while chirping and alerting the police.
A pop-up notice warned Jasmine to avoid the Seymour Street area; a robbery had just taken place there. She changed her course and headed westward instead. As she walked through a park, she noticed a man walking behind her. She quickened her pace—but so did he.
With a muffled curse, Jasmine tapped the arm of her glasses. Moments later two Blue Jays zipped over the park and began circling her follower.
He stopped and stared up at the Jays. Then his shoulders slumped and he turned away.
Jasmine continued on, completely alone and completely confident in the crisp early morning.
Bricks and mortar
As late-season ice storms went, this had been a particularly bad one. “That was where the ice dam built up,” said Paula, pointing to a spot on the roof where the orange plastic sheeting was hanging over one wall and was anchored with bricks. “The whole corner came down, and then the siding fell off!”
The house’s siding had been brick; what was left under the damaged wall was exposed joists and pink fiberglass insulation from the seventies. “The water leaked in—well, you can imagine the mess! And they tell me that repairing it will cost 30 thousand dollars! But you say you can do this printing thing for how much?”
“Fifteen thousand,” said the man. He nodded at the street where a gangly yellow crane-like vehicle sat. “It’ll take only a day. But we’ll have to remove the sheeting first, of course.”
“Oh, yes, that would be fine. But it’s going to look terrible, isn’t it? I mean, how are you going to match those bricks?”
“We won’t be using bricks. We’ll print concrete directly into the gap and texture it to look like bricks. The outside layer will be composed of amalgams that look like bricks where they’re supposed to, with mortar in between.” He held out a tablet and ran a little video for her. It showed a house similar to hers, with one whole side missing from an earthquake or some other disaster. She watched as the crane-like machine sidled up to it and began zipping back and forth and side to side, laying down tiny layers of concrete with perfect precision. It really did look like it was making actual bricks, but doing so in place.
“We’ll haul down the tarp, then I’ll send up a drone to do a laser scan and match the design and colours and so on. We’ll print insulation, wiring and coaxial cable right into the new wall. If you’ve always wanted another outlet or two on that wall, now’s the time to tell me.”
“Really?” Paula was intrigued, and the price was certainly right.
Usually, Paula got out of the way when contractors were around. It made her anxious to watch them tearing things apart. She eyed the back shed, where her lawn chairs had sat folded all winter.
“Can I watch?”
Tom arrived for work with a sense of relief and satisfaction. He had feared his days of working search and rescue were over after a serious accident forced him to move from his former town so he could be closer to the rehab centre.
But he was on call once again and, although he wouldn’t be physically rappelling down a cliff face or jumping out of a helicopter, his own thoughts would be controlling the robot that was.
For him, it was almost like magic—doing what he loved to do and feeling that rush of adrenaline again, and the pride of having successfully completed a mission. “These things we do so that others may live,” he said to himself, reading from the bold tattoo on his forearm.
A familiar audible tone sounded, indicating his next call was coming in. What would it be? A stranded boater? A frightened and lost hiker? He was ready for anything; he was back in the game.
As the interface positioned itself on his head, he answered the call. “This is Rescue Command . . . what’s your emergency?”
The emerging technologies could create significant new policy challenges over the next 15 years.
What is a policy challenge?
A policy challenge is an issue that current policies or institutions may not be ready or able to address. Identifying, analyzing, debating and clarifying a challenge helps us to develop a more robust strategy and the policy to handle it. Foresight helps identify emerging policy challenges.
In 2012, the number of Canadians with temporary jobs – often low-paying and with few benefits – was estimated to be 13.6% of the labour force and growing three times faster than traditional jobs. As these technologies evolve, we expect they will increase productivity but may result in more part-time work, short-term contracts, micro-jobs(link is external) and more foreign "virtual workers" (as described in MetaScan 2). Many have described these jobs as precarious as they lack security in terms of employment, income, skill and career development. As corporations try to reduce costs to increase competitiveness, the number of temporary jobs is growing. Should we look for ways to make these workers more productive? It is interesting to note that the high-income creative class and lower-income temporary workers face similar challenges and have similar needs.
A new social contract?
The social contract of the last century was that government, business and employed workers would contribute to social welfare programs. A growing number of short-term contract workers and freelancers are outside the current agreement. Given that freelancing is one of the fastest-growing segments in the labour market, it may be timely to explore new ways to bring freelancers into a new social contract.
The revival of co-operativism
One strategy to renew the social contract would be to support "mutualism." The Freelancers Union(link is external) is the fastest-growing union in the U.S. Members band together to set up social-purpose institutions to serve their mutual needs. Among other things, the union provides low-cost services(link is external), including health insurance, to its members. The emergence of freelancing is an echo of the co-operative movement in Canada, the guiding principles of which are mutual benefit and democratic governance. In a time of fiscal constraint, major new government programs are less likely. Are there policies and self-organizing institutions that could help freelancers deal with income variability?
New public policy instruments
Over the last several decades, there have been a variety of proposals and experiments to try to address the challenge of ensuring that people's basic needs are met. These include: basic income (an unconditional income grant to cover basic needs); guaranteed minimum income (a supplemental grant covering the difference between actual income and a guaranteed level), negative income tax; the guaranteed job; and others. The debate (link is external)goes on. The "flexicurity" model in Denmark which "combines flexible hiring and firing with a general social safety net" as well as other employment policies may be worth further study. An ongoing sub-issue of the debate is: how do we meet the basic needs of people caught in an economic transition, while avoiding freeloaders? AI and data analytics for a new, customizable transfer payment could help differentiate freeloaders from virtual workers and people learning new skills. It could also reduce the size of the bureaucracy, red tape and costs across three levels of government and possibly reduce other indirect costs (e.g., child poverty, stress-related health issues and failure to learn new skills).
Fewer jobs, fewer taxpayers
As new technologies replace workers, one challenge for government is fewer jobs may mean fewer taxpayers and less capacity to redistribute wealth through traditional transfer payments.
New technologies may disrupt the consensus on what constitutes equal and fair treatment for citizens. The technologies may level the playing field for some, while creating new barriers for others. The public policy questions include timing, efficacy and affordability.
Globalization and advances in technology have given rise to "plutocrats" such as superstar tech titans, bankers, chefs and writers, while diminishing opportunities for the middle class, according to Chrystia Freeland (2013). New technologies may affect income distribution. Economists are debating whether the shape of the income distribution is an hourglass or pyramid. In either case, the gap between rich and poor is likely to grow, and the low-skilled are likely to be worse off.
The technologies we adopt may serve to narrow or widen the equity gap, especially in the area of health care. Some injured and disabled will benefit from advances in areas like tissue engineering; however, high development and treatment costs could limit access. As we come to understand the human genome, determining what constitutes necessary and elective enhancement will become increasingly complex. Will genetic information lead to new forms of discrimination? In a world of customized medicine, what will constitute guaranteed health services?
Increasing social stratification
Some of the new technologies might promote social stratification. Emerging neurostimulation technologies and genetic selection will give enhanced cognitive powers to those able to afford them. Access to powerful AI and supercomputers will provide overwhelming advantage in financial markets, and advanced sensors may provide new means to safeguard privilege once it is achieved. Such developments may lead to a further stratification of individuals and groups not only in terms of wealth, but also in terms of what it means to be human.
Sensors and the artificial intelligence to use and interpret the information gathered by them will become cheaper, better and faster over the next 15 years. Advances in location sensing gives an indication of the trend. Recently, Google announced the goal to have smart phones in 2015 with positional accuracy within 10 centimetres, with sufficient resolution to notice you sitting up from your desk, taking a call or snuggling up to a partner. By 2028, a package that performs like today's smart phones could cost as little as $2 to produce. At that price, sensing will be nearly ubiquitous. Most people will carry one or several tools that measure ambient audio, location and air quality. Service providers and developers will be watching and listening to understand what's going on, what's around us and where we are, all to feed the helper applications that will support us in our daily lives. One's identity will be increasingly knowable as well. Today, digital chips track our identity and purchasing histories; in the future, face recognition, and gait and gesture recognition will help identify those not digitally broadcasting their presence to the world. Will our current rules and norms about privacy hold up in the face of improved sensing? Is privacy the right to be left alone, or is it the right to prevent others from knowing anything about you?
Are we ready for two-way surveillance?;
In The Transparent Society, David Brin argues that in addition to surveillance (the few watching the many), technological progress may foster a peer-to-peer model dubbed sousveillance (the many watching the few). A likely consequence is that preserving secret or private spaces, activities and actions will become both harder and more expensive. Are we prepared for an onslaught of openness?
Individual privacy versus public good
Along with the negative consequences of changes in privacy come great potential benefits. Suppose that one's health status, biometrics and protein levels were anonymously shared during each visit to a doctor's office. By combining these data with patients' genetic information, researchers could gain an enormous and fine-grained set of data that could be studied to understand patterns of viral and bacterial disease, chronic disease progressions, genetic susceptibilities and the effectiveness of specific interventions. The resulting benefits for the health care system would be incalculable. Similar benefits are possible in other fields. How can we structure the balance between privacy and the public good in the coming era of personal Big Data?
Infrastructure comes in many forms: transportation, buildings, services and communications technology, among others. There is a high probability that infrastructure of every kind will be influenced by the technologies explored in this foresight study.
- The fork in the road. Perhaps the most significant challenge will be deciding whether to maintain or update existing infrastructure, or to leapfrog and invest in entirely new infrastructure based on new technologies. As our current infrastructure continues to age, requiring significant investment simply to maintain the status quo, leapfrogging could reduce costs, greatly improve service and build competitive advantage.
- Who owns, who pays? In a world where everything is moving from centralized to networked, issues such as longevity, financing and return on investment will be more challenging. In the past, public utilities and governments provided infrastructure services as part of their commitment to creating public value, and citizens offset costs with their taxes and by paying utility bills. In a future that sees far greater decentralization (of energy, for example), what policies will need to be put in place to support the evolution of new models of infrastructure management?
- Longevity isn't so long any more. In the past, many infrastructure investments were expected to last decades and in some cases, even longer. As technologies evolve, the need to adapt quickly to replace infrastructure that is failing, or to accommodate the public's expectations for performance, efficiency and safety, will require initiatives that support scalable and modular approaches. The constant quest for better infrastructure solutions, in combination with science's push to develop better and safer options, could see the lifespan of certain investments becoming shorter.
- Innovate, demonstrate, test. In this period of transition, there will be many opportunities to experiment and test different approaches. Often, existing institutions, policies and regulations – and vested interests – can impede innovation. We need to encourage experimentation to overcome impediments. We can learn lessons from the open source movement about ways to ensure diverse innovations work together as a system.
The emerging technologies will make it harder to find and keep competitive advantage in the production of some goods and services. Bioproduction through synthetic biology will likely make it easier and cheaper to make some classes of goods. These technologies have the potential to help countries be more self-sufficient in some foods, fuels and materials. Advanced nanomaterials and nanodevices are likely to require a more educated workforce and more intricate production, resulting in a smaller number of competitors using these technologies.
A more level playing field for resources
Natural resources are a significant export for Canada. Will we need to rethink our strategy over the next decade or two? Some of our customers are going to use synthetic biology to make their own fuels, feedstock and primary goods. There may be an opportunity to move up the value chain and use synthetic biology to preprocess natural resources where we have a competitive advantage.
Governance as brand
In a world where production using synthetic biology or 3D printing can take place in a wider range of places, and where technology races can rapidly shift direction, it could be beneficial to brand the Canadian products that use these new technologies for their safety, design and added value. Government, business, science and non-governmental organizations will have to collaborate in new ways to ensure safe and responsible forms of production that will help Canada maintain a competitive position.
Risk management is an approach that allows governments to assess, implement and evaluate policy, regulations, processes – and, in some instances, even products and services – to ensure that standards for public safety are met. Current approaches to risk management rarely go beyond the short- and medium-term, focusing on only first- and second-order consequences. The discipline of foresight can assist by ystematically considering plausible futures, which can help uncover unexpected risks and buy time in the face of future challenges. As new technologies proliferate, the possibility of unforeseen consequences increases and citizens will look to governments to help them make sense of a potentially shifting terrain. This presents a variety of possible challenges.
Institutionalization of risk
Governments, through legislative and policy instruments (such as assessment and insurance regimes) have traditionally been active in helping understand and manage risk. New technologies are evolving rapidly and existing models of risk assessment and mitigation may not be able to respond in a timely fashion. What is essential for government to provide in terms of risk management? To what degree will the onus be on producers and consumers to be aware of and manage their own risk? Will the need to "assess" everything drive up costs?
Building science and technology literacy
Past experiences with genetically modified foods and other emergent technologies have shown that adoption of new technologies can have unexpected social, political and emotional dimensions. As new technologies evolve, what will be required to ensure a basic level of technology literacy so decision makers and the public have a good understanding of both risks and benefits?
Risk doesn't respect borders
As we have learned through experience, potential consequences of technology don't always stop at national borders. Global protocols have been required to address some of the more serious transnational effects of ozone-depleting substances and chemical pesticides. There is always the potential for such challenges to emerge as a consequence of new technologies. Will a plethora of uncoordinated national responses to potential risk increase the potential for global consequences? Are current national and international mechanisms adequate to anticipate, assess and manage such risks? Are we moving toward an international body to set standards for all?
The rate of change in science and technology is likely to accelerate, and science and technology are likely to play an increasingly important role in our economy and our lives. Product safety, public trust and competitive advantage will best be served by systems with efficient and timely testing and regulation.
Dealing with the exception
Emerging technologies will create many first-in-class products that may fall between current regulatory categories and practices. For instance, should direct-to-consumer neurostimulation be regulated as a medical device, a substance or a consumer product? Can we develop a safe system that is capable of revising regulations quickly enough to cope with new and unexpected substances and products?
Building science capacity
We need to try to anticipate where science and technology may go, and ensure we have appropriate skills and innovative testing methods. One complex area that may need attention is the rise of the talented amateur in areas like synthetic biology and 3D printing. While innovation should be supported, new ways to monitor or engage amateurs may be needed to capture problems before they leave the home lab.
The institutionalization of intellectual property (IP) regimes by national governments is designed to create economic incentives for research and development that, over time, may improve social welfare. The new technologies could help solve global problems in areas like health care, energy and security. Rigid and globally inconsistent IP regimes could allow IP owners to block innovation, limit the pace of development, exclude the possibility of new entrants and even threaten international relations.
Open source versus patent protection
Open source collaboration appears to be particularly appropriate and effective in the early stages of the development of new technologies. There have been remarkable open source successes over the last decade, such as Linux, Firefox and Android. This model is being adopted in the area of these new technologies as well, such as FabLab(link is external)'s 3D printing prototyping service, and open source biobricks in the field of synthetic biology. Such approaches aim to support open and ethical research to foster cumulative improvement and support results that could benefit people and the planet. They diverge, however, from the traditional business strategy of relying upon patent portfolios to ensure profitability for corporate entities. On one hand, there are uncertainties as to how to generate stable profits from open source technology. On the other hand, strong intellectual property protection is viewed as limiting innovation and raising the price of technology in the hightech sector. What is the appropriate balance between protecting intellectual property and promoting more rapid progress and collaboration? Who will invest in the research and development of important products that may have no patent protection and may never be commercialized in the traditional sense? What will we need to know to understand incentives for new entrants in an open source environment? What is the role of individual investors, financial markets and governments in an open source IP regime? Are there phases in the development of new technologies or innovation ecosystems that require different IP regimes?
Enforcement of IP rights under pressure
Notwithstanding a clear and strictly enforced IP regime, piracy will continue to be a factor. Emerging technologies will be subject to piracy themselves and will make piracy easier. For example, 3D scanners translate tangible products into data, which can then be 3D printed, or edited and modified. Given the advancements in materials science, this could make it possible to replicate a whole range of goods at home. This may increase patent and copyright infringement and affect manufacturing. How will different industries react to the loss of unilateral control that comes with replicative technologies? What is the role of national governments in protecting IP? Is criminalizing infringement the only approach?
The emerging technologies described in this study point to the importance of innovation as a key driver of the economy. Human capital, government policies, societal actors from all sectors and physical infrastructure are major elements of an innovation system. How can we redesign societal systems to maximize innovation?
Productivity measures for a digital economy
One of the biggest surprises of the digital era has been the dramatic amplifying power of technology on productivity; with anticipated improvements in artificial intelligence and robotics, this multiplication effect will only grow. New measures would help untangle those productivity gains which are due to technology and individual factors, and their interaction. Productivity measures that help us understand the competencies required in an innovative economy will allow us to develop skills accordingly.
Behavioural Traits that Support Innovation and Productivity
- A questioning disposition
- Openness to criticism
- Creativity and play
- Desire to solve problems
- Personal autonomy and self-starting approach
- Long-term orientation and gratification deferral.
Source: Characteristics & Behaviours of Innovative People in Organizations. Patterson et al.
Individual-level innovation approaches
Innovation research shows us that broader individual traits such as cognitive ability, personality, behaviour, motivation and emotion interact with knowledge to create innovative individuals. While some of these are not amenable to intervention, many are (text box). Can we improve Canada's innovation potential by systematically intervening to encourage these traits? For instance, we may gain by teaching innovation-oriented skills, such as solving problems by alternating between "generate" and "explore" phases, system mapping, constructive self-evaluation and experience with innovation-enhancing tools.
Corporate-level innovation approaches
Environments that systematize creative activities and encourage risk-taking and experimentation foster innovation. A decentralized organizational structure, shared vision and culture and flexible and supportive leaders and managers all support the innovative potential of staff. Training leaders how to foster innovation and co-creative environments would magnify the effects of individual level contributions. To be innovative, firms should become intrinsically global and pay more attention to attracting and retaining innovative talent. What strategies do we need to support innovation at all levels in society?
The Horizons' process looks at two kinds of assumptions. At the start of a process, we try to identify the "current assumptions" that are buried in current policy and dialogue. At the end of the process, we test these assumptions against the findings in the study to identify "credible assumptions" that appear to be robust across a range of futures. The assumptions that survive this testing are useful in shaping forward-looking research, policy and program development and decision-making.
Commonly Held Assumptions 2013
Credible Assumptions Looking Forward
Technological change is disruptive. We will figure it out when things stabilize.
We are in a period of transition. The pace of technologically driven change is going to accelerate as the technologies described in this study interact with each other.
Individuals and institutions underestimate the rate of change, and thus don't prepare adequately for it.
Most of the technological changes are incremental improvements in information technology and communications.
Manufacturing, services and natural resources will all be affected by new technologies.
The digital revolution (artificial intelligence (AI), sensors, data analytics) is quite mature and is impacting all sectors of the economy now. Biotechnology, nanotechnology and energy are ramping up with big impacts in 5 to 15 years. And neuroscience technologies could present some significant surprises in that period.
When the economic downturn lessens, there will be more full-time jobs with good salaries and pensions.
The new technologies will increase productivity with fewer workers. Non-standard jobs and project work will likely become more common, but they don't have to be precarious jobs.
Driven by technology, the logic of the market is creating a class of workers doing part-time contract work without benefits. They are essential to the operation of a competitive project economy. Creative thinking is needed to encourage innovation, recognize their contribution and share the risks. Many options exist to create a new social contract.
Canada is an attractive place for skilled workers.
Attracting, keeping and growing talented workers, especially in "the creative class" will require vision and cooperation at every level of government.
The creative class and project workers are key drivers in the emerging economy and in job groups with growth potential. They have similar needs. Cooperation across governments to support cities becoming innovation "clusters," building state-of-the-art health care, education and infrastructure, and developing supportive policies appears to be one way to attract, enable and keep them.
Billions of dollars are needed to repair and maintain aging infrastructure, and expansion means more of the same.
The new technologies may present opportunities to leapfrog to the next generation of infrastructure and reduce costs over the long term.
In areas like transportation, energy and health care, systematically and proactively exploring the full potential of the new technologies could help avoid investing in costly, but soon-to-be obsolete infrastructure while improving service at lower cost. Countries that leapfrog from old to next-generation infrastructure may have a competitive advantage.
The national economy matters.
A strong policy framework (responsible fiscal and monetary policy, promoting productivity, investment and trade) is a key tool in navigating a turbulent global economy.
An increasingly networked, integrated and interdependent global economy is emerging. Our policy tool kit and institutions need updating.
International cooperation to manage a globally networked economy, new kinds of safety, infrastructure and regulatory challenges, mobile virtual workers and a reinvention of health care and income support programs are needed. Some traditional national instruments will be ineffective in dealing with the emergent global systems. National policies could hinder growth if they are out of alignment with the major developed and emerging economies. But international cooperation that involves aligning interests and sharing sovereignty is notoriously difficult. Modernizing the policy framework will likely be incremental, experimental and possibly outside the current international institutions.
Current intellectual property (IP) and research and development regimes promote effective development.
Each stage in the development of a new technology may benefit from an evolving global ecosystem of information sharing, collaborative development, incentives, oversight and IP protection that balances the public good and private interests.
Currently, the corporations battle each other in court and the long-term public interest is assumed to be represented by market behaviour. Today's new technologies are going to play out over decades. Allowing private firms to lock down and shape large parts of that evolution in the very early stages of a new technology for their own benefit may not be in our long-term interest. Giving people what they want at an affordable price is proving to be the best protection against piracy in many fields.
- Aled Edwards,Structural Genomics Consortium
- Andrea Johnston, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Andrew Casey, BIOTECanada
- Andy Atkinson, Health Canada
- Anne-Christine Bonfils, National Research Council
- Brian Colton, Canadian Food Inspection Agency
- Burton Blais, Canadian Food Inspection Agency
- Christine Tibelius, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Colin Hoult, Canadian Forces
- Colin McGowan, Fisheries and Oceans Canada
- David Wilkinson, Public Health Agency of Canada
- Drew Endy, MIT
- Frank McDonald, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Gary Van Domselaar, Public Health Agency of Canada
- Giuliano Tolusso, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Jan Trumble Waddell, Public Health Agency of Canada
- Jim Louter, Environment Canada
- Joanne DeFranco, Export Development Canada
- Joseph Rios, Export Development Canada
- Klaus Ammann, University of Bern
- Mark Schaan, Industry Canada
- Matthew Brougham, Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health
- Nicholas Doucette, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Scott McNaughton, Health Canada
- Simone Petriw, Canadian Food Inspection Agency
- Titus Tao, Health Canada
- Vardit Ravitsky, University of Montréal
- Vicki Fleury, Canadian Food Inspection Agency
Neuroscience, Artificial Intelligence and Robotics
- Adrian Owen, University of Western Ontario
- Alan Mackworth, University of British Columbia
- Alex Mihailidis, University of Toronto
- Andres Lozano, University of Toronto
- Anthony Phillips, Canadian Institutes for Health Research
- Antoine Hakim, University of Ottawa (Brain and Mind Institute)
- Ashod Donikian, Navisens Pty Limited
- Chris Eliasmith, University of Waterloo
- Clifford Nass, Stanford University
- Colin Cherry, National Research Council
- Emil Petriu, University of Ottawa
- Eric Racine, McGill University
- Erick Dupuis, Canadian Space Agency
- Erik Vatikiotis-Bateson, University of British Columbia
- Gary Birch, Neil Squire Society
- Goldie Nejat, University of Toronto
- Isabelle Blanchette, Université du Québec à Trois Rivières
- James Danckert, University of Waterloo
- Jean Gotman, McGill University
- Jeff Daskalakis, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health
- Jennifer Chandler, University of Ottawa
- Jesse Hoey, Univerity of Waterloo
- John Verdon, Defence Research and Development Centre
- Jon Stoessl, University of British Columbia
- Jon Wolpaw, Wadsworth Center, NY State Department of Health
- Karim Nader, McGill University
- Mary Boreskie, Industry Canada
- Matthew Lovett-Barron, Columbia University
- Peter Danielson, University of British Columbia
- Peter Suma, University of Waterloo
- Ravi Menon, Robarts Research
- Vincent Clark, University of California
- William Graf, Yale University
Nanotechnology and Energy
- Andrew Atkinson, Health Canada
- Arthur Carty, Nano Ontario
- Brad Feasey, Industry Canada
- Brian Colton, Canadian Food Inspection Agency
- Brian Haydon, Canadian Space Agency
- Chris Kingston, National Research Council
- Clayton Teague, Former NNCO Director
- Clive Willis, CWIC Inc.
- David Curtis, Hydro One
- Dolores Martinez, Nano Quebec
- Frank McDonald, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Geoffrey Sunahara, National Research Council
- Gitanjali Adlakha-Hutcheo, Defence Research Development Council
- Jason Lo, Natural Resources Canada
- Kim Ryel, Foreign Affairs, Trade and Development Canada
- Marie D'Iorio, National Research Council Canada
- Matthew Shacker, Natural Resources Canada
- Mihail Roco, U.S. National Science Foundation
- Nicholas Doucette, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada
- Nicole Buckley, Canadian Space Agency
- Nicole Davidson, Environment Canada
- Pekka Sinervo, Canadian Institute for Advanced Research
- Peter Grütter, McGill University
- Robert Crawhall, Consultant
- Robert Pohanka, U.S. National Nanotechnology Coordination Office (NNCO)
- Sabin Boily, École de Technologie Supérieure
- Saeed Khan, Industry Canada
- Thomas Davis, Canadian Space Agency
- Thomas Ducellier, National Research Council Canada
- Tim Karlsson, Industry Canada
- Vanessa Clive, Industry Canada
- Warren Chan, University of Toronto
- Yasir Sultan, Environment Canada
The following scenarios are not attempts to predict the future. Rather, these scenarios provide an opportunity to consider how the future might emerge, allowing decision makers to understand how different planning assumptions may play out over time. They allow us to evaluate existing and proposed policy approaches against a range of plausible futures and to identify possible surprises.
Although any, or none, of the scenarios may play out, they support the development of a more robust understanding of the future. For the purposes of this study, four analytical scenarios have been developed that examine the economic, social and governance landscapes within the context of the rapidly evolving technologies explored in this study.
Business, government and public cautious about new technology
Caution is the order of the day in terms of investment, adoption and policy related to new technologies. Some technologies, such as synthetic biology and 3D printing, have begun to transform the manufacturing, agriculture and natural resources sectors. Artificial intelligence is starting to change the services sector. But adoption of technologies by governments, businesses and individuals is slow because of concerns about long-term profitability, an uncertain regulatory environment and their potential impact on everything from environmental risk to privacy. This situation has been further complicated by poor coordination among levels of government to foster technological innovation, build upon global opportunities and update risk management approaches that support effective regulation of products and processes. As a consequence, economic growth is slow in Canada, but not in the new economic superpowers emerging in Asia. In those countries, support for new technologies, investment and science and technology literacy is high and growing. Canadian workers with the right skills are in high demand, but adoption of some of these technologies is displacing lower-skilled workers. But high-skilled workers are also facing considerable pressure as virtual work and global competition drive down wages. These factors are slowing immigration and many high-skilled workers are leaving Canada or working virtually for foreign firms. The policy response has relied heavily upon encouraging individuals to continue to build their skills, but Canadians are increasingly concerned about the growing number of people with precarious work. Canada is maintaining an increasingly dated public infrastructure with static or decreasing public revenues. Consequently, opportunities to leverage newer technologies and infrastructure to improve public outcomes are sometimes missed.
Back to the Future: Headlines from 2028
"Canada part of growing global rare earth boom as autonomous robots deployed to Baffin Island mining operation"
"Calgary loses bid to host Tech Giant BioSynth Labs to Indonesia – municipal officials blame other levels of government and community activists for loss of jobs and growth"
Business leads, government supportive, public concerned
The pace of technological change and adoption is largely set by business in an environment of supportive governance. Although economic growth is stable, personal wealth is not and the number of jobs is static or shrinking. Technological uptake is rapid. Industry is leveraging synthetic biology and robotics to improve efficiency in manufacturing and natural resource extraction and processing, areas where there is high commercial profitability and markets for commodities in emerging markets. Although there is low coordination among levels of government, some cities and provinces are working to find their niche within the growing global technology marketplace. The governance emphasis is on positioning industry to succeed in an increasingly competitive global environment. There is growing underemployment and unemployment among both low- and high-skilled workers, both as a consequence of a growing global market in virtual work and increases in non-standard work. Large urban centres continue to grow as workers move to areas where technology is creating opportunities; however, "ghettoes" are emerging as Canadian virtual workers compete with skilled virtual workers from other countries for low wages. As a consequence, and in light of shrinking public revenues, this period is characterized by policy experimentation. This includes society and governments making creative use of alternative policy models, such as social impact bonds and public-private partnerships, to leverage business capacity to support broader public objectives. Similar approaches are being taken regarding infrastructure, which is in a state of considerable decline. In some areas, such as transportation, those in charge of publicly owned infrastructure are experimenting with new models of shared public and private ownership and management. The degree to which public goods, institutions and infrastructure are modernized is determined by their relevance to business needs.
Back to the Future: Headlines from 2028
"Over 2 000 jobs lost as retail giant replaces truck fleet with autonomous freight-movement systems"
Stakeholders collaborate to design robust strategy
New technologies are having a significant impact on all sectors of the economy. Diverse actors are working together to engineer systems that foster efficient and coordinated processes that minimize risk to society. Industrial processes characterized by closed-loop systems are the ideal. As opportunities are identified and exploited, frequent and rapid changes in direction are required by industry and governments. The policy framework fosters entrepreneurship by remaining adaptable and by supporting an environment where risk is shared among governments, industry and other actors. Concerns about the impact of new technologies remain, but have been reduced by the supportive policy environment, education, and an evolving sensor network that demonstrates that, although not without risk, new technologies are safe and improving quality of life. Work is precarious, particularly for the low-skilled, as a consequence of global competition and the growth of non-standard work. An updated social contract, however, is allowing workers to take time to upgrade their skills and to compete globally. Government invests in understanding and supporting the importance of innovation and integrates it across all systems (from policy, program design and delivery, to investments and partnerships in both domestic and global research and development). Canadian workers and commodities are in considerable demand both domestically and globally. Transportation, energy and communications infrastructure are being renewed to support the cultural and economic shift towards an innovation economy.
Back to the Future: Headlines from 2028
"Increases in non-standard work and new global opportunities make choosing a career path more challenging, say new grads"
Open source innovation in global networks becomes key driver
Innovation is a global phenomenon and the results of technological innovation are largely open source. As a consequence, innovation is occurring more rapidly and benefits are more equitably distributed. The creative commons is borderless and characterized by a community of innovators that builds constructively upon one another's work. The intellectual property system has evolved and innovators are rewarded by micro-payment systems. The Canadian economy is growing slowly in an environment of hypercompetition. Workers at all levels need to be mobile, flexible, adaptable and transdisciplinary. Even low-skilled manufacturing and service jobs are now shaped by rapid technological innovation. In response, the social policy framework provides ongoing support for skills development and "flexicurity." This approach recognizes that technological change is constantly redefining the world of work and that society and individuals require support to adapt. Infrastructure is modular and, increasingly, globally linked. Interoperability is the ideal, but complicated by the rapid pace of innovation. Government services at all levels involve high levels of automation, in particular, artificial intelligence and robotics (in areas from taxation, social programs, and health care through to national defense). The national government is increasingly constrained by the need for increased global coordination.
Back to the Future: Headlines from 2028
"AI-enhanced Global Health Tracking Network now includes 96 countries and growing – coordinated tracking and responses to disease outbreaks improving health outcomes worldwide"
- Interviews and reading to frame and understand the problem
- Track core assumptions to test
- Identify insights / weak signals that change is occurring
- Assess relevant trends
- Elaboration of commonly held assumptions
- Identify key elements in the system
- Describe key relationships
- Describe change drivers shaping the system
- Influence maps of second- and third-order consequences
- Preliminary examination of the interaction of drivers
- Scenarios to explore range of futures
- Identify potential challenges and discontinuities
- Testing for robust assumptions and strategies
- Credible assumptions and key uncertainties
- Policy challenges
- Emerging issues
- Data needs
The Future of Small Business Manufacturing OPEN Forum." YouTube video. MSNBC. May 19, 2013. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=62oFiwJXxnE(link is external)
Amonix Inc. "Amonix achieves world record 35.9% module efficiency rating at NREL," news release. August 20, 2013. http://amonix.com/pressreleases/amonix-achieves-world-record-359-module-efficiency-rating-nrel-4(link is external)
Andersen, Torben M. , Nicole Bosch, Anja Deelen, and Rob Euwals. 2011. "The Danish flexicurity model in the Great Recession." Vox. April 8, 2011. http://www.voxeu.org/article/flexicurity-danish-labour-market-model-great-recession(link is external)
Anderssen, Erin. 2013. "As more women become bigger breadwinners, the news isn't all good." The Globe and Mail. May 29, 2013. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/the-hot-button/as-more-women-become-bigger-breadwinners-the-news-isnt-all-good/article12247901/(link is external)
Anthony, Sebastian. 2013. "MIT shows off huge solar cell efficiency boost by throwing nanowires into the mix." ExtremeTech. March 26, 2013. http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/151605-mit-shows-off-huge-solar-cell-efficiency-boost-bythrowing- nanowires-into-the-mix(link is external)
"Artificial Intelligence." Department of Computer Science, University of Toronto. Undated. http://web.cs.toronto.edu/research/areas/ai.htm(link is external)
"Australia's BHP to introduce robot mining trucks." The Globe and Mail video. 2012. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/video/video-australias-bhp-to-introduce-robot-mining-trucks/article4809072/(link is external)
"Autodesk's Carl Bass on using technology to solve civilization's problems: The future is now." YouTube video. Autodesk. November 5, 2012. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E0VjJCDR50A(link is external)
Bostrom, Nick and Eliezer Yudkowsky. Forthcoming (2011 draft). "The ethics of artificial intelligence," in William Ramsey and Keith Frankish (eds.), Cambridge Handbook of Artificial Intelligence. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. http://www.nickbostrom.com/ethics/artificial-intelligence.pdf(link is external)
"Building resilience in the transition to a digital economy and a networked society." Policy Horizons Canada. 2012. http://www.horizons.gc.ca/eng/content/building-resilience-transition-digital-economy-and-networked-society
Bullis, Kevin. 2013. "A Material That Could Make Solar Power 'Dirt Cheap.'" MIT Technology Review. August 8, 2013. http://www.technologyreview.com/news/517811/a-material-that-could-make-solar-power-dirt-cheap/(link is external)
"Cancer Nanotechnology Plan." National Cancer Institute. 2010. http://nano.cancer.gov/about/plan/(link is external)
Cantley, Mark. 2007. "The bioeconomy to 2030: Designing a policy agenda." International Futures Project. OECD. http://www.oecd.org/sti/futures/long-termtechnologicalsocietalchallenges/42837897.pdf(link is external)
Ceallaigh, John. 2013. "The world's first 3D printed house." The Telegraph. August 27, 2013. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/ultratravel/the-next-big-thing/10110195/The-worlds-first-3D-printed-house.html(link is external)
Cortes, Ulises, Roberta Annicchiarico, Javier Vazquez-Salceda, Cristina Urdiales, Lola Canamero, Maite Lopez, Miquel Sanchez-Marre and Carlo Caltagirone. Undated. "e-Tools: The use of assistive technologies to enhance disabled and senior citizens' autonomy." University of Barcelona. http://www.maia.ub.edu/~maite/papers/etools_EULAT.pdf(link is external)
Deutsche Bank. 2010. "The end of the Oil Age: 2011 and beyond." Global Markets Research. December 22, 2010. http://bioage.typepad.com/files/1223fm-05.pdf(link is external)
Element Energy. 2012. Cost and performance of EV batteries: Final report for the Committee on Climate Change. Cambridge. March 21, 2012. http://www.element-energy.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/CCC-battery-cost_-Element-Energy-report_March2012_Finalbis.pdf(link is external)
Elsässer, Markus. 2013. "As solar costs drop, energy storage solutions take center stage." Renewable Energy World.com. July 24, 2013. http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/article/2013/07/as-solar-costs-drop-energy-storage-solutions-take-center-stage(link is external)
Ellzey, Curtis. 2008. "Microalgae bioreactor." Engineering tv video. April 24, 2008. http://www.engineeringtv.com/video/Microalgae-Bioreactors(link is external)
Freeland, Chrystia. "The age of global plutocracy." TEDGlobal video. June 12, 2013. http://blog.ted.com/2013/06/12/the-age-of-global-plutocracy-chrystia-freeland-at-tedglobal-2013/(link is external)
"Global Directory of Biobanks, Tissue Banks and Biorepositories." SpecimentCentral.com. http://specimencentral.com/biobank-directory.aspx(link is external)
Gonsalez, Robert. 2013. "This new discovery will finally allow us to build biological computers." i09.com. http://io9.com/this-new-discovery-will-finally-allow-us-to-build-biolo-462867996(link is external)
"Google Glass: video user guide released." Theguardian.com video. May 1, 2013. http://www.theguardian.com/technology/video/2013/may/01/google-glass-user-guide-released-video(link is external)
Grant, Tavia. 2013. "Canada's shift to a nation of temporary workers." The Globe and Mail. May 8, 2013. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/jobs/canadas-shift-to-a-nation-of-temporary-workers/article11721139/(link is external)
"Hang on a minute." Science Museum. http://www.sciencemuseum.org.uk/antenna/nano/lifestyle/146.asp(link is external)
"Harvard study uses brain-to-brain interface to move a rat's tail." YouTube video. April 4, 2013. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VaJjHgyHnEc(link is external)
Hautmann, Daniel. 2013. "Nordic countries fight ice with nanotech." New Energy. March 8, 2013. http://www.newenergy.info/knowledge/technology/nordic-countries-fight-ice-with-nanotech(link is external)
Hensley, Russell, John Newman, and Matt Rogers. 2012. "Battery technology charges ahead." McKinsey & Company. July 2012. http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/energy_resources_materials/battery_technology_charges_ahead(link is external)
Hollister, Sean. 2010. "DoE forecasts far cheaper, lighter, longer-lasting EV batteries by 2015." Engadget.com. July 22, 2010. http://www.engadget.com/2010/07/22/doe-forecasts-far-cheaper-lighter-longer-lasting-ev-batteries/(link is external)
Horowitz, Sara. 2013. "Welcome to the micro-gig: No job is too small." The Atlantic. April 10, 2013. http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/04/welcome-to-the-micro-gig-no-job-is-too-small/274843/(link is external)
"Human enhancement and the future of work." Report on workshop held March 7, 2012. The Academy of Medical Sciences, British Academy, Royal Academy of Engineering and the Royal Society. http://royalsociety.org/policy/projects/human-enhancement/workshop-report/(link is external)
Jay, Paul. 2007. "Human-machine relations: Warning robots ahead." CBC. July 16, 2007. http://www.cbc.ca/news2/background/tech/robotics/robot-warn.html(link is external)
Joint Center for Energy Storage Research. 2010. "The national mission." http://www.jcesr.org/research/the-national-need/(link is external)
Lasserwasser, Christoph (ed.) Undated. "Small sizes that matter: Opportunities and risks of nanotechnologies." OECD International Futures Program and Allianz AG. http://www.oecd.org/science/nanosafety/37770473.pdf(link is external)
Loos, Marcio R., Cristimari R.O. Loos, Donald L. Feke, Ica Manaszloczower. Undated. "World's first carbon nanotube reinforced polyurethane wind blades." Case Western Reserve University. http://engineering.case.edu/emac/news/Carbon-Nanotube-Reinforced(link is external)
Luca, Thierry. "Autodesk se met à la biologie." L'usine digitale. Le mardi 9 juillet 2013. http://www.usine-digitale.fr/article/autodesk-se-met-a-la-biologie.N200985(link is external)
Luzar, Charles. 2013. "Kickstarter funding from glowing plants crosses $250,000." Crowdfund Insider. May 8, 2013. http://www.crowdfundinsider.com/2013/05/15091-kickstarter-for-glowing-bioluminescent-plants-crosses-250k/(link is external)
Luzar, Charles. 2013. "Kickstarter bans GMOs in wake of glowing plant campaign." Crowdfund Insider. August 3, 2013. http://www.crowdfundinsider.com/2013/08/20031-kickstarter-bans-gmos-in-wake-of-glowing-plantfiasco/(link is external)
Meador, Michael A., Bradley Files, Jing Li, Harish Manohara, Dan Powell, and Emilie J. Siochi. 2010. "Draft nanotechnology roadmap." National Aeronautics and Space Administration. http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/501325main_TA10-Nanotech-DRAFT-Nov2010-A.pdf(link is external)
"Micro Air Vehicles buglike drones." Youtube video. General Dynamics for US Air Force Research Laboratory. October 19, 2009. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCZCQOg-zKs(link is external)
"Microsoft vision for the future of technology in health." YouTube video. Microsoft. March 24, 2009. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jt8JqVdaTqI(link is external)
MNT Network. Undated. "Nanotechnology for more efficient wind energy." http://www.nano.org.uk/members/MembersReports/WindPower.pdf(link is external)
"Nanotechnology Subsector Study: Canada's evolving nanotechnology industry and future implications for the ICT labour force." 2011. Information and Communications Technology Council. http://www.ictc-ctic.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/ICTC_NanoTechExecSummary_EN_06-11.pdf(link is external)
"NANOTECHNOLOGIE, où en sommes-nous?" July 2008. http://www.reptox.csst.qc.ca/Documents/PlusEncore/Nanotech/Pdf/capsuleNANO.pdf(link is external)
Nanotechnology now: Your gateway to everything nanotech. http://www.nanotech-now.com(link is external)
"Nanotechnology: Small is Different: A Science Perspective on the Regulatory Challenges of the Nanoscale." Council of Canadian Academies. http://www.scienceadvice.ca/en/assessments/completed/nanotechnology.aspx(link is external)
National Nanotechnology Initiative. http://www.nano.gov/(link is external)
"Nerosolutions frequently asked questions." NeroDimension Inc. 2013. http://www.neurosolutions.com/products/ns/faq.html(link is external)
NewComb, Doug. 2013. "What it's like to ride in a self-driving car." Wired video. February 7, 2013. http://www.wired.com/autopia/2013/02/continental-autonomous-vehicle/(link is external)
NBC News.com. 2011. "Need superfast, cheap DNA? Try the 'printer': Chip process could have broad implications for drug making, genetic cloning." Innovation on NBC News.com. June 1, 2011. http://www.nbcnews.com/id/43241170/ns/technology_and_science-innovation/t/need-superfast-cheapdna- try-printer/(link is external)
Nye, Jeanne, Andrew Greenberg, and Angela Jones. Undated. "Nanotechnology in transportation." http://ice.chem.wisc.edu/NanoDecisions/PDF/Transportation.pdf(link is external)
Ostiguy, C. 2007. "Nanotechnologie : vers la prochaine réunion industrielle." Travail et santé. Vol. 23, no 4. p. 11-14.
Ostiguy, C. et al. 2006. Les nanoparticules : connaissances actuelles sur les risques et les mesures de prévention en santé et en sécurité du travail. Studies and Research Projects Report. Montréal: l'Institut de recherche Robert-Sauvé en santé et en sécurité du travail (IRSST). http://www.irsst.qc.ca/(link is external)
Ostiguy, C. et al. 2008. Les effets à la santé reliés aux nanoparticules. Studies and Research Projects Report. Montréal: l'Institut de recherche Robert-Sauvé en santé et en sécurité du travail (IRSST). http://www.irsst.qc.ca/(link is external)
Parkinson, Giles. 2013. "Citigroup: How solar module prices could fall to 25c/watt." REnew Economy. April 1, 2013. http://reneweconomy.com.au/2013/citigroup-how-solar-module-prices-could-fall-to-25cwatt-41384(link is external)
Patterson, Fiona, et al. "Characteristics and Behaviours of Innovative People in Organisations." Literature Review. NESTA Policy Research Unit. United Kingdom: London. http://www.nesta.org.uk/publications/characteristics-and-behaviours-innovative-people-organisations(link is external)
"Printing Australia's largest solar cells." CSIRO. May 16, 2013. http://www.csiro.au/Portals/Media/Printing-Australias-largest-solar-cells.aspx(link is external)
Psarakis, Cynthia (ed). 2013. The Robot Kingdom (single issue magazine). Science Illustrated. March/April 2013. http://www.amazon.com/Science-Illustrated-March-April-Kingdom/dp/B00CGC2ZFS(link is external)
"Renewable energy for America." Natural Resources Defense Council. Undated. http://www.nrdc.org/energy/renewables/wind.asp(link is external)
Renwick, Shane. 2011. "ForeCan: Foresight for Canadian animal health." CFIA/CAHLN. http://cahln-rctlsa.com/uploads/2/7/7/9/2779116/1130_mon_renwick.pdf(link is external)
"Roadmaps in nanomedicine. Towards 2020." 2009. Joint European Commission. Platform Nanomedicine. Expert Report 2009. http://www.etp-nanomedicine.eu/public/press-documents/publications/etpn-publications/091022_ETPN_Report_2009.pdf(link is external)
Roco, Michail C., Chad A. Mirkin, and Mark C. Hersam. 2010. "Nanotechnology research directions for societal needs in 2020 retrospective and outlook." Science Policy Reports. Boston and Berlin: Springer. http://www.wtec.org/nano2/(link is external)
Rocky Mountain Institute. 2013. "Solar PV balance of system." http://www.rmi.org/rmi/SolarPVBOS(link is external)
Saenz, Aaron. "Japanese robot picks only the ripest strawberries." Singularity Hub video, December 4, 2010. http://singularityhub.com/2010/12/04/japans-robot-picks-only-the-ripest-strawberries-video/(link is external)
Shierholz, Heidi. 2013. "The wrong route to equality – men's declining wages." Economic Policy Institute. June 12, 2013. http://www.epi.org/publication/wrong-route-equality-mens-declining-wages/(link is external)
"Smart elevators to get you there faster." CBC News. March 22, 2013. http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/story/2013/03/22/tech-schindler-responsive-elevator.html(link is external)
Sorensen, Chris. 2012. "End of the job: A world of freelancers and contract workers may be good for business, but bad for the economy." MacLean's. January 20, 2012. http://www2.macleans.ca/2012/01/20/the-end-of-the-job/(link is external)
Steadman, Ian. "The race to build the first 3D-printed building." Wired. June 4, 2013. http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-06/04/architecture-and-3d-printing(link is external)
Stewart, Jon. 2012. "Robot racing car aims for pole position." Hyperdrive. November 2, 2012. http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20121102-robot-car-aims-for-pole-position(link is external)
"Sustainability, benefits to the community and ethics in the assessment of genetically modified organisms." The Norwegian Biotechnology Advisory Board. 2009. http://www.bion.no/filarkiv/2010/07/2009_11_18_diskusjonsnotat_baerekraft_engelsk.pdf(link is external)
"Synthetic beef hamburger tastes 'close to meat.'" Theguardian.com video. August 5, 2013. http://www.theguardian.com/science/video/2013/aug/05/synthetic-beef-hamburger-tastes-meat-video(link is external)
"Synthetic biology explained: Putting the engineering back into genetic engineering." YouTube video. Bridge8. August 9, 2011. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rD5uNAMbDaQ(link is external)
"Switchblade Drone soon to be used by federal police all across America." Aerovironment. January 15, 2012. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-dgvBb5ke-E(link is external)
Tate, Ryan. 2013. "Meet the common man's robot: Headless and adorable." Wired. February 27, 2013. http://www.wired.com/business/2013/02/common-mans-robot/(link is external)
"Technology innovation." NBC News. http://www.nbcnews.com/technology/topic/innovation/(link is external)
"Technology and innovation futures: UK growth opportunities for the 2020s." Government Office for Science, Government of the UK. 2012. http://protohub.net/technology-and-innovation-uk-growth-opportunities-for-the-2020s-2012-refresh/(link is external)
"The Cancer Genome Atlas: Understanding genomics to improve cancer care." National Cancer Institute. http://cancergenome.nih.gov/(link is external)
"The future of oil." The Economist. August 3, 2013, p. 20-22. http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21582516-worlds-thirst-oil-could-be-nearing-peak-bad-newsproducers- excellent(link is external)
"The future of work." PSFK Labs. 2013. http://www.slideshare.net/PSFK/psfk-presents-future-of-work-report?ref=http://www.psfk.com/ publishing/future-of-work(link is external)
The International Barcode of Life. iBOL. http://ibol.org/(link is external)
"The Precariat: The new dangerous class." YouTube video. UNRISD Seminar Series. September 2011. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYoaV6f78wM(link is external)
Tobe, Frank. 2013. "China now largest market for robots." Everything Robotic blog by The Robot Report. July 11, 2013. http://www.everything-robotic.com/2013/07/china-now-largest-market-for-robots.html(link is external)
"Tracking the business of robotics." The Robot Report. August 27, 2013. http://www.therobotreport.com/(link is external)
Trottier, E. et al. 2006. Éthique et nanotechnologies : se donner les moyens d'agir. Commission de l'éthique de la science et de la technologie. http://www.ethique.gouv.qc.ca/fr/assets/documents/Nano/ResumeAvisNanos_FR.pdf(link is external)
Truchon, G. et al. 2008. La recherche en nanotechnologie. Par où commencer ? Travail et santé. Vol. 24, no 2. p. 32-35.
"UK Bioinformatics: Current Landscapes and Future Horizons." Department of Trade Industry, Government of the UK. 2002. http://www.cric.ac.uk/cric/projects/bioinformatics/pdfs/report.pdf(link is external)
"Vineland's robotics and automation trials move into planting and packaging phase." Vineland. 2013. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39pwCEYadmw#at=38(link is external)
Wisland, Laura. 2012. "Good news for solar prices." The Equation. Union of Concerned Scientists. December 3, 2012. http://blog.ucsusa.org/good-news-for-solar-prices(link is external)
Yoon, Lan. 2013. "10 ways biotechnology could improve our everyday life." Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology. http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2013-02/tkai-ttw022513.php